So... Just because I need somewhere to get this out.
Why the fuck can't they get these movies right? Like, come ON, guys. Seriously. I have several grievances.
1. What's up with Ron/Lavender being like, 90% of the focus of the film? Sure, it was funny, but it could have been greatly reduced to make room for much more interesting stuff like the House of Gaunt/the flashback when Voldemort asks for the DADA job. I mean, both of the younger Voldemorts were really good, but I wanted to see Ralph Fiennes work it out, y'know?
2. Yates cannot direct actors. For serious. I KNOW that Alan Rickman was capable of that huge emotional, freaking out scene as he escapes the grounds, but it came out really flat, anticlimatic, and just not moving in any way, shape, or form. Which pissed me off, because that was one of the things I was most looking forward to. And how did it happen? "Uh... I'm the HBP khtxbai" *flees*
3. Ginny. Just...Ginny. Direction? Maybe. But I think she just can't act in general. And not just poor little Bonnie Wright, but also Daniel Radcliffe, because together they have about ZERO PERCENT chemistry. And not just those two. But Steve Kloves decided to destroy the most important part of their relationship, and reduced it to just "okay, now they kissed, I guess that wraps that up".
4. Of course only I have a problem with this, maybe, but the soundtrack sucked the BIG one. The opening number was actually really haunting, and that was it. It's like Nicholas Hooper was like "Eh, I only need one good song in this movie, right?" I don't think there was one powerful, resounding theme in that movie. I was expecting some sweeping ballad for Ginny, but never got that. And even some really touching melody for Dumbledore and Harry, to reprise when he died, but nope. None of that either. JOHN WILLIAMS. COME BACK. PLZ.
5. The best part was the comedy. By far. Rupert Grint is just great, and although the jokes weren't that clever, they worked. I thought the scene where Harry drinks the felix felicis was funny too, although a good amount of people disagree with me. Luna was good, as always. And Lavender Brown, although I think a bit overexposed, was also good.
6. The best performances go to Tom Felton and Jim Broadbent, easily. I think Felton did really well with the little scenes he was given--he definitely got across the tortured, angst part of himself no problem, which for some reason proved to be a bit of a problem for Radcliffe, unfortunately. Broadbent was so great. He was wonderful, most notably in the scene where he finally gives Harry the memory.
7. Dumbledore's death scene. Really? Okay... Wait, we're serious about this? All right, guys... We don't want to--Okay, okay. Fine. That's just...That's just great.
8. WHERE DID THE FREAKING AWESOME BATTLE GO? THERE WERE KIDS SNOGGING. THAT WAS IT. THAT'S NOT AN EPIC BATTLE SEQUENCE. Also, Helena Bonham-Carter just going crazy. Which is welcomed, I guess, but to a certain extent.
9. Why did they set the Burrow on fire? I don't know. It was completely pointless. The only good that came of it were some interestingly shot sequences in the fields. Otherwise, pointless. They were maybe making a misguided attempt at strengthening Harry and Ginny's relationship... maybe? But yeah, who knows where everyone's going to start the next movie off, considering the Weasley house is apparently now a pile of ashes.
10. Okay, Bruno Delbonnel deserves some applause. That movie was pretty. Probably the prettiest of the series. But that really can't save it, as much as I want it to. But man, that high angle shot of Draco on the floor of the bathroom, and his blood against all the white and grey was fantastic. So yeah, props to him. Oscar nod? Maaaaaaybe.
So yeah, done ranting. I was talking to a lot of people, and I think why other movies like Lord of the Rings and Star Trek have done so well is because they were written, directed, and produced by huge fans, who made it because they love it and want to make it well. I think with the Harry Potter movies, the series is too young for any of the big players to have any kind of passion for the source material. So perhaps that's why the adaptation keeps falling flat.